‘Most important man in accounting’ warns against lowering standards

Keep knowledgeable with free updates

Merely signal as much as the Accountancy myFT Digest — delivered on to your inbox.

Barry Melancon, dubbed “an important man in accounting” for his 30-year management of its skilled physique within the US, has despatched a stern warning to his successors that they need to not compromise requirements in an effort to draw extra individuals to the occupation.

Melancon is retiring this month because the longest-serving chief government of the American Institute of Licensed Public Accountants, overseeing a occupation that has been remodeled by new expertise and personal fairness funding however finds itself in throes of a recruitment disaster.

With younger individuals lured by the upper salaries and decrease entry necessities of finance and expertise, the variety of individuals taking the CPA examination run by the institute has fallen sharply, and accounting corporations have demanded reforms to make it cheaper and faster to get certified.

In a wide-ranging interview with the Monetary Occasions, Melancon expressed scepticism about a few of the corporations’ claims, and mentioned a race to the “lowest frequent denominator” might come again to hang-out the occupation.

“We’re a extremely trusted occupation and we stay in a world that doesn’t have a variety of touchstones on belief,” he mentioned. “We have to respect the respect that we get from the general public and from the enterprise group and from regulators.”

A scarcity of accountants has been blamed by some corporations for potential flaws of their monetary statements, and a few US native governments and corporations have complained that it’s tougher to seek out auditors.

After initially resisting stress from the occupation, the AICPA in September proposed scrapping a requirement that accountants have the equal of 5 years of college schooling, often known as the 150-hour rule — a yr greater than a typical undergraduate diploma’s 120 hours of programs.

Melancon made it clear he had doubts concerning the want for such a change. “The 150-hour rule elevated our occupation, which within the Nineteen Seventies was oriented extra like a commerce than a occupation. It elevated the standard of individuals in our occupation, and the standing of our occupation, and to disclaim that’s to disclaim historical past.”

Melancon was the youngest-ever head of the AICPA when he took the helm in 1995 on the age of 37, and he has not flinched from pushing by means of adjustments up to now. He insisted on computerising the CPA examination when some within the occupation resisted, and made the qualification out there internationally. He additionally championed the creation of audit techniques and different expertise that could possibly be shared amongst corporations. The journal Accounting Right this moment has constantly ranked him probably the most influential individual within the occupation.

A brand new flashpoint is over the element of the on-the-job coaching that the AICPA has designed as an alternative choice to a fifth yr of college schooling for CPA candidates.

The FT has reported that the group representing massive accounting corporations needed a simpler system than the one proposed, which might require supervisors to certify that new recruits have obtained dozens of particular expertise, or “competencies”.

Critics say the plan is just too advanced, expensive and subjective, however Melancon mentioned guaranteeing new accountants had particular competencies was very important to forestall a “lowest frequent denominator drawback” the place an unskilled practitioner might deliver the occupation into disrepute.

“Corporations don’t take their funding within the individuals they rent frivolously, so it actually shouldn’t be an enormous change for the overwhelming majority of corporations,” he mentioned.

The proposed adjustments come towards the backdrop of a office that’s quick evolving, with much less want for armies of junior workers doing repetitive duties and new alternatives for accountants to make use of their enterprise and monetary acumen to assist purchasers.

“Entry-level positions in our occupation can be lowered . . . resulting from expertise, and the normal pyramid form of a public accounting agency shouldn’t be going to be the construction of the longer term,” Melancon predicted.

“We’ve to develop investments in competency enhancement that extra rapidly will get individuals into that center a part of the agency or the finance operate, the place the occupation is so invaluable.”

Additionally altering the form of the occupation is the arrival of personal fairness, which has acquired a 3rd of the 30 largest US corporations since 2022. In addition to promising to fund expertise funding, the offers present windfalls for older companions and fairness to incentivise youthful ones. Regulators, nonetheless, have warned that non-public fairness possession threatens the objectivity of audit work, whereas a must maximise income might decrease requirements.

“I don’t suppose the normal partnership construction is the one means our occupation can operate,” Melancon says. Whereas he welcomed the experimentation, he added that “anyone that thinks [private equity deals] are all going to be marriages made in heaven shouldn’t be proper”.

In the end, accounting corporations are more likely to discover traders that may maintain them for the long-term quite than flip them, he mentioned.

For one last prediction earlier than his retirement, Melancon makes use of a quote he has had in his workplace for many years. “Change,” he says, “won’t ever be as gradual as it’s right this moment.”